Investigating the role of economics in tackling issues in global agricultural development
Thursday, March 25, 2010
Drink coffee, fight poverty (hmm, I like the sound of that)
So all of us know at least SOMEthing about Starbucks. Even non-coffee drinkers recognize that they have a cool logo. And those who work there part-time in college (or after) know that they offer great employee benefits.
Well Ive got to make another shout out to Starbucks, and its for their CAFE Practices certification program.
In my opinion, this appraoch (social business) is one great way to fight poverty.
First of all, its a fact that of the billions of dollars spent by the US government and NGOs (including well-meaning Christian ones) to fight poverty fail to make much of a difference (according to Paul Collier, University of Oxford; Hillary Clinton, US Secretary of State to name a few). This is due to a number of factors including politics, inefficiency and corruption.
Its also a fact that businesses have both influence and power. Thats where Starbucks comes in. They've created a certification for coffee farmers called CAFE Practices which provides producers with a premium price for their coffee in exchange for adherance to specific quality, social, and environmental guidelines.
So youre probably thinking, well thats just Fairtrade, but Starbucks has taken the whole thing a step further. (Not to get into too many details, but Fairtrade doesnt actually help small farmers a whole lot, at least not in Nicaragua).
Starbucks, as part of their business initiative, not only offers certification and technical advice, but small loans to farmers as well. This allows farmers to purchase better equipment, often with their neighbors, to make their farms more efficient and improve the quality of their coffee to reach Starbucks expectations. Starbucks has experienced a Gramean-bank-like 99% repayment rate (extremely rare, by the way). Why?
Starbucks, as a business has the power to create pressure, a factor that is gaining influence in this globalized world. They have a vested interest in the sucess of the farmers it has loaned money too. The farmers have an incentive to repay the loans, recognizing that a continued relationship with Starbucks ensures them technical advice and higher coffee prices. Its mutually beneficial.
Besides finances, CAFE Pratices is doing a great deal to lift people out of poverty. Poverty is very much a psycological problem. Most rural poor in Nicaragua, instead of taking the initiative to better their own lives, have become reliant on handouts. They often feel like they have no value, no voice, and no future, which further encourages them to do nothing. Starbucks has changed that attitude in many ways. Farmers under CAFE Practices recognize that they too can take part in the global economy. They have something that the world wants, they have power, they can make changes that will affect their own future. Starbucks is the link thats making it happen.
PAC actually has a model very similar to Starbucks, with 120 of their small coffee farmers currently in the first (of 3) years needed to obtain CAFE Practices certification, with hope to increase the number of certified farmers each year.
While CAFE Practices isnt perfect, it's still an impressive effort thats making a difference. It makes me glad to see that not every aspect of large corporations are bad, at least not in the mind of small Nicaraguan coffee producers.
Tuesday, March 23, 2010
¡Mis amigos catrachos!
Rich business men come to talk and get their shoes shined
Friday, February 26, 2010
The Beach!
Monday, February 8, 2010
Coffee anyone?
The bus ride between Granada and Ocotal is a total of about six hours.
Which leaves plenty of time for the already
struggling buses to break down!
Discussing the new plan to gather data with
managers and technicians.
My church on the weekends back in Granada.
My 20 year old host brother, Mario, sharing in church. It's
great having a brother like him, we get along really
well and have great times hanging out!
Monday, January 11, 2010
The Project
In fact, here in Nicaragua the official work week is 6 days a week, 8 hours a day without siestas (yes, I was definitely a little disappointed).
Anyways, as far as my work with PAC goes I feel both challenged and excited about the next several months. The project that PAC has asked me to do is a little complicated, but I will give it my best shot to explain. Basically, over the last several years PAC has collected information from farmers and small businesses (like acres, yields, prices received, etc.) However, there is no standard for gathering this information and it is kept in numerous formats on numorous computers in numerous different databases.
This information is extremely valuable for PAC because it can be analyzed to obtain what are called "indicators." These indicators can be used both for PAC as an organization and farmers or small businesses to make more informed decisions.
So my job is to create a stadard way to collect and analyze the information. It has been an interesting challenge, as I have had the chance to interview and work alongside farmers, technicians, managers, IT guys, and everyone in between, trying to figure out the best way to do this. It's cool because in many ways my education fits right into this project and I feel like I am contributing to PAC's overall mision. I am also of course learning a ton along the way, and if you happen to be an expert in this field, feel free to contact me!
Aside from work, I have had the chance to help out with sunday school at my church, kids ages 5 to 7. The kids are so much fun, always very happy and energetic!
Wednesday, January 6, 2010
Thoughts on poverty
There was a coffee plantation halfway up with free samples, so good!
Check out the view from the top, Granada is in the background
The top of the volcano is a cloud forest
It was so green, with moss and ferns covering everything
What is poverty?
After living in Nicaragua for almost two months I am beginning to get a clearer sense of poverty and the different approachs used to fight it. Here are some thoughts on what poverty is from the book, When Helping Hurts, as well as from talking to people working in development organizations, and talking to the poor themselves:
- the lack of education
- money
- clean water
- food
- medication or access to any form of healthcare
- aduquate shelter
BUT, it's more than the physical, it is also
- powerlessness
- humiliation
- inferiority
- fear
- and depression
It can be caused by both personal choices as well as the system (government, economy, social, and religous) that surrounds the poor. It is interesting because people's view on the cause of poverty directly affects what they do about it. I feel honored to work for an organization that understands the complexity of poverty, recognizing that change requires long term work. I guess thats why they call it development! More thought on this later...
A waterfall that was in the backyard of a family that sometimes struggles to feed themselves.
Saturday, December 19, 2009
And we raise hogs???
PACs newest project over the last 3 years or so has been to increase the production of cacao in Nicaragua. The climate is ideal here, it's just that farmers lacked the knowledge and marketing skills. Cacao has very quickly become a great cash crop for 100s of poor farmers, with much hope to expand. Here are a few snapshots of the process...
amount considering average income here is around $20 per week.
Of course he has a family to feed as well.
a definite excitement about cacao here!
Wilmur, a cacao producer himself that collects cacao from 15
other local producers in order to ferment it, then resell it.
it is then sold to an exporter. This pickup load is about
1500 pounds, worth about $1500.
(In comparison, coffee at this stage would be worth about $900).